The Glory Days: 2020s
- 2020 — Jackie Crawford
The Awakening: 2010s
- 2019 — Kelsie Chase
- 2018 — Kelsie Chase
- 2017 — Kelsie Chase
- 2016 — Jackie Crawford
- 2015 — Erin Johnson
- 2014 — Jackie Hobbs (Crawford)
- 2013 — Hope Thompson
- 2012 — Erin Johnson
- 2011 — Erin Johnson
- 2010 — Lari Dee Guy
The Die-Hard Decade: 2000s
- 2009 — Tana Felhauer
- 2008 — Lari Dee Guy
- 2007 — Tammy Lewis
- 2006 — Leigh Ann Billingsley
- 2005 — Kim Williamson
- 2004 — Kim Williamson
- 2003 — Tami Noble
- 2002 — Nora Hunt
- 2001 — April Harms
- 2000 — Ashlee Miller
The Golden Age: 1990s
- 1999 — JJ Hampton
- 1998 — Rhonda Harrison
- 1997 — Lisa Gasperson
- 1996 — JJ Hampton
- 1995 — JJ Hampton
- 1994 — Lisa Gasperson
- 1993 — Lisa Pulse-Gasperson
- 1992 — Jimmi Jo Martin
- 1991 — Jimmi Jo Martin
- 1990 — Jayme Reaves
The Pioneers: 1970s and 1980s
- 1989 — Betty Gayle Cooper
- 1983 — Heather Hodson
- 1983 — Heather Hodson
- 1975 — Becky Fuchs
- 1974 — Becky Berggren
